档案价值鉴定理论范式的三重转向：基于文献的系统性述评

[1] 张斌. 关于档案价值鉴定的理论与实践(七)—鉴定活动论:鉴定标准与价值判断[J]. 档案学通讯, 2002(1):22. [2] Cook T, Schwartz J M. Archives, records, and power: from(postmodern)theory to(archival)performance[J]. Archival Science, 2002(3-4): 171-185. [3] [4] 韩玉梅, 黄霄羽. 外国档案管理自学指导[J]. 档案学通讯, 1998(6):73. [4] [45] T. R. 谢伦伯格. 现代档案—原则与技术[M]. 黄坤坊,等, 译. 北京: 档案出版社,1983:22,36-40. [5] 张斌. 论档案价值鉴定标准体系[J]. 中国档案, 2000(4):41. [6] 陈忠海. 欧美现代档案鉴定理论的历史发展及启示[J]. 档案学通讯, 2000(2):10-11. [7] 李媛媛, 桑毓域. 汉斯·布姆斯及其社会分析和职能鉴定理论探析[J]. 档案学通讯, 2014(5):29. [8] 汪孔德. 关于宏观职能鉴定论的理性思[J]. 档案与建设, 2004(4):18. [9] Jonker A E. Macroappraisal in the Netherlands. The First Ten Years, 1991-2001, and Beyond[J]. Archival Science, 2005(2): 203-218. [10] Cunningham A, Oswald R. Some Functions are more equal than others: the development of a macroappraisal strategy for the national archives of Australia[J]. Archival Science, 2005(2): 163-184. [11] Giesbrecht R, Smith J M. Everything old is new again: the evolution of Generic Appraisal at Library and Archives Canada[J]. Archivaria, 2017(1): 37-59. [12] Kim Y. A study on public records appraisal policies in the digital age: based on the case of The National Archives in the UK[J]. The Korean Journal of Archival Studies, 2019(62): 5-39. [13] 王琳, 赵彦昌. 21世纪以来档案鉴定研究述评—基于7种核心期刊的学术考察[J]. 档案学刊, 2022(3):8. [14] [17][20][21] 汪孔德. 档案价值鉴定研究[M]. 合肥: 安徽大学出版社,2009:81,85-86,87-92,93-95. [15] 陈兆祦, 和宝荣. 档案管理学基础[M]. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社,1996:180-182. [16] 张斌. 档案价值论[M]. 北京: 中央文献出版社,2000:1-14. [17] 傅荣校. 档案鉴定理论与实践透视:基于效益与效率思路的研究[M]. 北京: 中国档案出版社,2007:63-99. [18] 汪孔德. 论档案鉴定的本位原则[J]. 档案学研究, 2003(5):15. [19] 杨茜茜. 档案鉴定理论体系重构探析—基于我国档案鉴定概念演变的思考[J]. 档案学通讯, 2018(5):28-29. [20] Mojapelo M, Maleka J. The electronic records appraisal approach: a case study of the construction education and training authority[J]. Mousaion: South African Journal of Information Studies, 2023(1): 1. [21] Anderson B, Eaton F, Schwartz S W. Archival appraisal and the digital record: applying past tradition for future practice[J]. New Review of Information Networking, 2015(1-2): 3-15. [22] Seol M W, Kim Y. Revisiting archical appraisal theories for their application to community archives[J]. The Korean Journal of Archival Studies, 2016(48): 210-252. [23] Lambert J. The management team and archival appraisal[J]. Archivaria, 2005(59): 109-117. [24] Makhlouf Shabou B, Tièche J, Knafou J, et al. Algorithmic methods to explore the automation of the appraisal of structured and unstructured digital data[J]. Records Management Journal, 2020(2): 175-200. [25] Bayeck R Y, Colavizza G, Bunn J, et al. Recommendations on using artificial intelligence in archival appraisal and selection[J]. Liverpool University Press, 2022(1): 219-225. [26] Sherman J, Morrison R, Klein L, et al. The power of absence: thinking with archival theory in algorithmic design[J]. Designing Interactive Systems Conference, 2024: 214-223. [27] Cox R J. Appraisal and the future of archives in the digital era[M]// Hill J. The future of archives and recordkeeping:a Reader. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011: 213-237. [28] 马伏秋. 论我国档案鉴定工作之“销毁鉴定”[J]. 档案学研究, 2015(4):85. [29] 周林兴, 邓晋芝. 错位的价值判定应该被纠正—对档案鉴定及销毁的历史视域考量[J]. 档案学通讯, 2015(2):38. [30] 杨冬权. 档案价值鉴定[J]. 中国档案, 2017(10):27. [31] 杨冬权. 从“选时代”到“全时代”—智慧社会档案工作的历史性转折[J]. 中国档案, 2021(1):77-79. [32] 马仁杰. 关于档案价值鉴定的若干问题[J]. 安徽大学学报, 1997(4):73-74. [33] 谢诗艺. 回归与反思—对档案鉴定的多维视角认识兼与周林兴教授商榷[J]. 档案学通讯, 2015(4):15. [34] 孙大东. 档案鉴定的历史和现实视域考量—与周林兴、邓晋芝二位作者商榷[J]. 档案学通讯, 2015(5):15-17. [35] 王增强. 理论与实践:档案存毁之间并无博弈—与周林兴、吕维商榷[J]. 档案学研究, 2017(2):22-23. [36] 周林兴. 档案价值是负载于档案的一种社会关系[J]. 山西档案, 2022(2):1. [37] [62] 周林兴. 漏斗式档案价值判定模型构建—一种基于社会关系的价值认知方法[J]. 浙江档案, 2025(1):26,27. [38] [63] 娄海婷. 对漏斗式档案价值判定模型及其应用的辩疑—兼与周林兴教授商榷[J]. 浙江档案, 2025(9):29-31,30. [39] Jennkinson H. A manual of archive administration[M]. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1992: 150-156. [40] Tschan R, 蔡娜, 吴开平. 詹金逊和谢伦伯格鉴定观之比较[J]. 档案与建设, 2005(1):19. [41] [56] 刘东斌. 档案鉴定—由谁鉴定—档案鉴定基本问题思考之二[J]. 档案管理, 2006(3):25-26, 26. [42] Ellington J K, Wilson M A. The performance appraisal milieu: a multilevel analysis of context effects in performance ratings[J]. Journal of Business and Psychology, 2017(1): 87-100. [43] Cook T. We are what we keep; we keep what we are: archival appraisal past, present and future[J]. Journal of the Society of Archivists, 2011(2): 173-189. [44] Lee K R. The distribution of responsibility and authority upon public record appraisal: focused on "Citizen Participation Appraisal"[J]. The Korean Journal of Archival Studies, 2019(60): 49-88. [45] Bayhylle R E. Tribal archives: a study in records, memory and power[D]. Los Angeles: University of California, 2011: 195-208. [46] Hodge S, Nantel S, Trainor C. Remnants of Jenkinson: observations on settler archival theory in Canadian archival appraisal discourse[J]. Archives and Records, 2022(2): 147-160. [47] Shilton K, Srinivasan R. Participatory appraisal and arrangement for multicultural archival collections[J]. Archivaria, 2007(1): 87-101. [48] Sucha-Xaya N. Finding values, building communities: development of an archival appraisal system for the Thai public sector[J]. Archival Science, 2024(3): 329-349. [49] 张纳昕. 档案宏观职能鉴定理论中的公民观阐释[J]. 档案与建设, 2023(1):57-58. [50] [57] 谭彩敏. 新时期档案价值鉴定研究:背景、标准、主体[J]. 北京档案, 2019(12):27-28,27. [51] 孔维冲. 档案价值鉴定标准体系的构建[J]. 中国档案, 2023(6):66. [52] 陈勇, 谢晓平. 德尔菲法在档案价值鉴定中的应用[J]. 中国档案, 2009(12):37-39. [53] Lin S K. A study on the appraisal of archival values for electronic records[J]. Journal of Educational Media & Library Sciences, 2010(2): 35-42. [54] 杨沩杰. 数智时代下档案价值鉴定工作:存续逻辑、多维拓展与路径重构[J]. 浙江档案, 2025(9):28. [55] 杨千, 李星玥. 数字时代档案鉴定非必要论辨析与匡正[J]. 档案学通讯, 2023(1):50. [56] Edquist S. The politics of archival appraisal in Sweden in the digital age[M]// BakG, RostgaardM. The Nordic Model of Digital Archiving. London: Routledge, 2023: 42-59. [57] [77] Schwartz J M, Cook T. Archives, records, and power: the making of modern memory[J]. Archival Science, 2002(1): 1-19. [58] Harris V. The archival sliver: power, memory, and archives in South Africa[J]. Archival Science, 2002(1): 63-86. [59] 何小菡. 论权力与档案鉴定的相互建构[J]. 档案, 2020(2):10. [60] [85] 徐拥军, 张群群, 卢思佳. 档案记忆观视角下档案工作者角色定位的反思[J]. 档案学研究, 2025(4):6,8. [61] 丁华东, 余黎菁. 论特里·库克的档案记忆思想[J]. 档案管理, 2014(6):7-8. [62] [76] Greene M A. The power of meaning: the archival mission in the Postmodern Age[J]. The American Archivist, 2002(1): 42-55. [63] 徐欣欣, 周冉瑶. 社群范式下对档案概念的新思考[J]. 档案学刊, 2024(3):8-11. [64] 陈智为. 档案社会学概论[M]. 天津: 南开大学出版社,1989:13. [65] Cook T. Evidence, memory, identity, and community: four shifting archival paradigms[J]. Archival Science, 2013(2): 95-120. [66] Duranti L, Franks P C. Encyclopedia of archival science[M]. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2015: 321-322. [67] Garaba F. The state of archival appraisal practices in the ESARBICA Region[J]. African Journal of Library Archives & Information Science, 2007(1): 59-63. [68] T. 库克. 铭记未来—档案在建构社会记忆中的作用[J]. 李音,译. 档案学通讯, 2002(2):75. [69] 闫静, 刘洋洋. 档案中的认同悖论—兼论档案对身份认同的作用机制与机理[J]. 档案与建设, 2021(3):11-14. [70] Samuels H. Who controls the past[J]. The American archivist, 1986(2): 109-124. [71] Hackman L, Warnow-Blewett J. The documentation strategy process: a model and a case study[J]. American Archivist, 1987(1): 12-47. [72] 于华. 馆藏珍贵档案鉴定原则[J]. 中国档案, 2016(1): 43. [73] Ketelaar E. Archival temples, archival prisons: modes of power and protection[J]. Archival Science, 2002(3): 221-238. [74] 周林兴, 吕维. 价值与认知:档案存毁之间的博弈[J]. 档案学通讯, 2016(5):32. [75] 周林兴. 重申弱化档案价值鉴定的合理性存在[J]. 档案学通讯, 2016(2):32. [76] Kretzschmar R. Archival appraisal in Germany: a decade of theory, strategies, and practices[J]. Archival Science, 2005(2): 219-238. [77] Warren K E. We need these bodies, but not their knowledge: black women in the archival science professions and their connection to the archives of enslaved black women in the French Antilles[J]. Library Trends, 2016(4): 776-794. [78] Harris V. Antonyms of our remembering[J]. Archival Science, 2014(3): 215-229.